Become a supporter of Family First NZ
Join the Family First Mailing List
In this issue (9 February)...
1. Kahui case: When will twins get justice?
2. Abstinence education works - study
3. Time to auction off prostitution law
4. Govt must clarify school 'fees' or 'donations'
5. Counseling helps mums-to-be with abusive partner
6. Family dinners, sleep and less tv reduces obesity - study
7. To Raise Happy Kids, Put Marriage First - New Book
8. Teen girls sucked into crime by older men
9. TAKE ACTION: Wellington March This Friday Opposing Family Planning Abortion License

Follow Bob McCoskrie on 'Twitter' and 'Facebook'
Family First National Director Bob McCoskrie has joined the ‘twitterverse’ and also has a page on Facebook. Be the first to know about issues affecting families, how you can respond, and see the media coverage of what Family First is saying in the public domain. Become part of the growing family activist movement for strong families and marriages, and safe communities.
Follow Bob McCoskrie on Twitter today at http://twitter.com/familyfirstnz and on Facebook http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?ref=name&id=1193302986 


1. Kahui case: When will twins get justice?
Sunday Star Times 07 February 2010
The inquest into the deaths of one of New Zealand's most high-profile child killings has been postponed indefinitely. Three-month-old South Auckland twins Chris and Cru Kahui were killed in June 2006, and their father Chris Kahui was acquitted of their murders in 2008. Since then the case has stalled, and the murders remain unsolved. Last October the chief coroner set an inquest date of February 22 in the Auckland District Court, but according to the court that date has now been "vacated". No new date has been set. READ MORE
WATCH Bob McCoskrie from Family First speaks to TVNZ's Breakfast.
Minister of Justice Simon Power responds
Minister of Justice Should Demand Kahui Inquest
MEDIA RELEASE 8 February 2010
Family First NZ is calling on the Minister of Justice to demand that the chief coroner ensure that the Kahui inquest happens as soon as possible. “The twins were murdered in 2006 and we are still waiting on both justice to be delivered and now the inquest to happen,” says Bob McCoskrie, National Director of Family First NZ. READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


2. Abstinence education works - Study
MEDIA RELEASE 3 February 2010
Family First NZ is welcoming research which shows that abstinence-only education can help teens delay sex, and also explodes the myth that abstinence education reduces condom use amongst those who do become sexually active. “NZ parents have long supported their children being taught abstinence, self control and good choices rather than the flawed ‘we don’t want you to but here’s how anyway’ method currently short-selling our young people,” says Bob McCoskrie, National Director of Family First NZ. The study from the University of Pennsylvania involving 600 students and published in the journal Archives of Paediatrics and Adolescent Medicine found that half of the group taught sex education reported they had sexual intercourse over the next two years compared to one third of the group given the abstinence lessons. The researchers said ‘Abstinence-only interventions may have an important role in delaying sexual activity until a time later in life when the adolescent is more prepared to handle to consequences of sex. This can reduce undesirable consequences of sex, including pregnancy and sexually transmitted infections like HIV and Aids.READ MORE
Abstinence classes might work: study
NZPA 03/02/2010
Educators are being asked to take another look at sex education for 11 to 13-year-old students in light of a recent study from the United States that suggests abs10tinence programmes could persuade young people to delay sexual activity.  ...New Zealand lobby group Family First has welcomed the study and has called on the education sector to take another look at the sex education curriculum. http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/education/3289378/Abstinence-classes-might-work-study
Children taught sex ed more likely to have intercourse younger - study
Mail Online (UK) 2 February 10 READ MORE
Abstinence-only programs might work, study says
Washington Post February 2, 2010 READ MORE
READ the study
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


3. Time to Auction Off Prostitution Law
MEDIA RELEASE 2 February 2010
Family First NZ says that a 19 year old student raising her university fees by ‘prostituting’ her virginity online is an example of the outcome of a flawed prostitution law and it should be immediately repealed. “It's every parent's worst nightmare that their daughter would prostitute herself to pay fees, or that their son would act as a pimp to raise funds to study,” says Bob McCoskrie, National Director of Family First NZ. “To end up raising $45,000 shows that unfortunately there are many people who simply see women as a commodity to be purchased. When the politicians decriminalised prostitution, it still didn't make it right. There is huge stigma against prostitution and quite rightly.” READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


4. Government Must Clarify School ‘Fees’/‘Donation’
MEDIA RELEASE 5 February 2010
Family First NZ says that the government must clarify to parents whether school fees are compulsory or not. “The mixed messages and confusion under the Labour government have continued with the National government,” says Bob McCoskrie, National Director of Family First NZ. “This has confused parents and resulted in some parents paying the fees and others refusing. In the end, the whole school community is penalised by the uncertainty and the subsequent shortfall.” READ MORE
Parents Can Claim School Fees Refund
MEDIA RELEASE 5 February 2010
Family First NZ is reminding and possibly informing parents that when they complete their IRD Tax Returns for the financial year ended 31 March 2010, they are entitled to claim back 1/3’rd of their school fees. “Amidst the debate on whether school fees are compulsory or not, many parents aren’t aware that school donations qualify for the Donations Rebate,” says National Director Bob McCoskrie. “This rebate which now has no cap means that parents can get a refund of a third of the school donation. This may be welcome news to families struggling with beginning-of-year expenses.” READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


5. Counseling helps mums-to-be with abusive partner
Reuters Health 4 Feb 10
In a large study conducted in Washington, D.C., a short intervention reduced repeat episodes of domestic violence among a group of pregnant African-American women. The intervention also made it less likely for the pregnancy to end in very premature births. The intervention involved counseling sessions during prenatal care visits. READ MORE
Family First Comment: This study confirms that proactive intervention and support of young mothers and families during pregnancy and after the child is born is an effective insurance policy against abuse and domestic violence. Read more www.stoptheabuse.org.nz
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


6. Family dinners, sleep and less tv reduces obesity
Telegraph (UK) 08 Feb 2010
Young children should live as they did a generation ago to help prevent obesity, a new study shows. Four-year-olds who ate dinner with their siblings and parents, got a lot of sleep and had their TV viewing rationed were found to have a reduced risk of becoming seriously overweight. Children who followed these routines – more in line with children 25 years ago - were almost 40 per cent less likely to be obese than those from less disciplined households. READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


7. To Raise Happy Kids, Put Marriage First - New Book
Daily Mail Online (UK) 07th February 2010
Couples who want to raise happy and successful children should spend less time striving to be perfect parents and prioritise their own relationship instead. In a new book, U.S. family therapist David Code warns that children become demanding and dissatisfied if parents obsess over all aspects of their lives. Couples who want the best for their children should focus less on becoming the ideal parent and spend more time nurturing their own relationship. READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


8. Teen girls sucked into crime by older men
The Nelson Mail 06/02/2010
 More teenage girls are turning to crime and violence after becoming addicted to drugs and alcohol through their older boyfriends, a Nelson lawyer says. His observations are backed up by groundbreaking research being done by social anthropologist Donna Swift, who says the teenage girls in trouble with police for violence or anti-social behaviour she deals with, often have boyfriends four or five years older. READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


TAKE ACTION:
Wellington March This Friday
Opposing Family Planning Abortion License


Currently approximately 18,000 abortions are committed in New Zealand every year. The Family Planning Association is applying for a licence for their Hamilton office to administer RU486, a medical abortion procedure. This drug is used for killing foetuses up to 9 weeks post-conception. The first pill starves the pre-born child of nutrients while the second pill causes a premature birth. If the Hamilton Clinic gets a license, the other 29 FPA clinics will be next.
Please stand up today for the silent generation.
March Details: 12:30pm, Friday 12 Feb, meet at Civic Square - marching to Parliament. MORE DETAILS


 



In this issue (2nd February) ...
1. Student offers her virginity for sale online
2. Women's virginity 'a precious gift' - Aust Opp'n Leader
3. Marriage IS what matters most to family stability (UK)
4. Married men earn third more than single men (UK)
5. Young families most likely to break up - Aust research
6. Fat parents to blame for childhood obesity - UK study
7. Studies point to latent problems in childcare
8. GST rise will hurt poor the most
9. Working for Families tax trap


1. Student (19) offers virginity for sale online
Herald on Sunday Jan 31, 2010
A cash-strapped Kiwi student (19) is selling her virginity to the highest online bidder. READ MORE (UPDATE - the winning bid was $45,000!)
Family First Comment: It's every parent's worst nightmare that their daughter would prostitute herself to pay fees, or that their son would act as a pimp to raise funds to study. When the politicians decriminalised prostitution, it still didn't make it right. There is huge stigma against prostitution and quite rightly. But when the MP's foolishly decriminalised it, the underlying message to younger people was that we condoned it - which was completely out of sync with public sentiment. We'd encourage the 19 year old to keep her virginity and her dignity. The website should also remove the ad.
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


2. Women's virginity 'a precious gift' - Aust Opp'n Leader
Herald Sun January 26, 2010 
Tte Australian Opposition Leader said he believed women should regard their virginity as "a gift' that should not be given away lightly. But Deputy Prime Minister Julia Gillard said Mr Abbott’s comments confirmed the worst fears Australian women had about him. “Australian women want to make their own choices and they don’t want to be lectured to by Mr Abbott,” Ms Gillard said. The Opposition Leader ... fleshed out his advice on virginity, urging men to not act in ways that “demean others” but suggesting young women should not “give themselves away lightly”. READ MORE
See also - Opposition leader Tony Abbott vilified for being a dad READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz



3. Marriage IS what matters most to family stability (UK) Only 3% of unmarried couples stay together until their child is 16
Mail online 21st January 2010
Marriage is more important than all other factors in family stability, according to new research which demolishes (UK) Labour's central argument against tax breaks for wedded couples. Harry Benson, of the Bristol Community Family Trust, said: 'Based on data of 15,000 new mothers, marriage is the single biggest predictor, above and beyond the effects of income, education, age, ethnic group, benefit receipt and birth order. 'In a new analysis using census data, I found that 60 per cent of families remain intact until their children are 15. Of these, 97 per cent are married." READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


4. Married men earn a third more than single men
Mail Online (UK) 30th January 2010
Married men earn nearly one third more than single males because they work harder, new research reveals. READ MORE 
Family First Comment: These are just two example of evidence that marriage matters. Read a summary of the tens of thousands of research material on the physical, emotional, psychological, developmental, health and financial benefits of marriage. It all begs the question - why won't the government or its government agencies such as the Families Commission and Children's Commissioner talk about it or encourage it!?
DOWNLOAD REPORT "Why Marriage Matters"
Visit the website of the NZ Marriage Coalition http://nzmarriage.org.nz/
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


5. Young families most likely to break up (Aust) 
The Australian February 01, 2010
Couples who separate tend to be poorer, less educated and more likely to be unemployed or suffer from mental illness than couples who stay together, according to new research. Separated couples are also more likely to have infants and preschoolers in their care, as opposed to older children. The findings, from the Australian Institute of Family Studies report on the family law system, also found extremely high levels of alcohol abuse, drug abuse, mental illness and gambling in families that ended up before the court, with half the mothers saying that one or more of these issues were present. READ MORE
Family First Comment: Notice that all these same at-risk factors are present for child abuse and domestic violence. These are the families who must be targeted with resources, parenting programmes, intervention, and where necessary, the full weight of the law.
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


6. Fat parents to blame for child obesity - UK study
Telegraph (UK) 31 Jan 2010
Overweight parents who simply feed their children too much at a young age are to largely blame for Britain’s childhood obesity crisis, a report will warn this week. The study claims that the Government may be misguided in its policy of trying to tackle the problem through expensive projects aimed at persuading children in primary school to eat healthily and exercise more. Instead, the report suggests, they should focus on educating new parents and parents-to-be to feed their children less before they start school, so they do not become overweight in the first place. Parents must learn to reduce portion sizes it suggests. READ MORE
See also - Passive parents make for fat kids
Sunday Star Times 30/08/2009
Children are more likely to be fat if their parents are inactive, according to an AUT study. READ MORE
Family First Comment: This research is consistent with what we have been saying regarding the obesity epidemic. Young people will always find ways around school tuckshop bans and regulations. The real way to tackle this issue is through the parents - the gatekeepers to the family food supply, who also set the example
Families Need to own the issue of obesity - by Bob McCoskrie (published in the NZ Herald 2007) READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


7. Studies point to latent problems in childcare
NZ Herald Jan 28, 2010
The number of children under 2 in childcare leaped 47 per cent in the nine years to last July and now includes 25 per cent of all infants under 2. With 57 per cent of 2-year-olds also in care, New Zealand's total of 36 per cent of all those under 3 in childcare is now among the highest in the world - in 2005, when the NZ figure was 32 per cent, we were seventh-highest out of 28 OECD nations. Children's Commissioner Dr Angus has raised concerns about the resulting risks for reduced breastfeeding, disrupted attachment to parents, more exposure to infectious diseases, more stressful interactions and aggressive behaviour. National Women's Hospital paediatrician Simon Rowley, a trustee of the Brainwave Trust, says research has found that levels of the stress hormone cortisol rise during the day for infants in childcare, in contrast to the normal pattern of being high in the morning and falling through the day. READ MORE
A child's place is in the home - by Bob McCoskrie (published in the NZ Herald Sep 2007) READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


8. GST rise will hurt poor the most
NZ Herald Jan 30, 2010
Raising GST to 15 per cent would increase living costs for the poorest New Zealanders more than twice as much as for the rich, unless low income tax rates are cut to compensate. READ MORE 

9. Working for Families tax trap
NZ Herald Jan 30, 2010
Nearly 378,000 New Zealand households get a bit more money each week through Working for Families tax credits. But a system designed to help young families actually punishes them as extra income earned from hard work is taxed at rates as high as 90c in the dollar. For some families, the dole is a better option. READ MORE

Read also: Penalty Tax for being married as high as $15,000 - Family First Media Release Oct 2008 READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz





Happy new year! While the country has enjoyed the new year and summer break, we've been monitoring family issues. Here's a summary of the key ones. (please excuse the length of this update - we're making up for the last month!!)
 
In this issue....
1. Priority 2010 - Protect Children From Sexualisation and Abuse
2. Latest Smacking Research Shows Benefits
3. Time Out Targeted as Next Taboo of Parenting
4. Marriage is what matters most to family stability
5. Victims dad applauds three strikes law change
6. Crown to appeal decision that carer parents should be paid
7. Porn less immoral than piracy - survey 
8. Watching TV for hours could shorten your life - study
9. Grieving mother blames cancer vaccine
10. Suicide link to a lack of sleep
11. Scandalous show pulled from Christmas stage
12. New Research: Why Never Spanking Might Be Worse for Kids Than Spanking Them


1. Priority 2010 - Protect Children From Sexualisation and Abuse

Family First Media Release 31 December 2009
Family First NZ has released its annual list of the top family issues to be tackled, and heading the list for 2010 is the protection of children from ‘corporate pedophilia’ and reducing the ‘raunch culture’ which is harming the self-esteem, body image and academic performance of young people – especially young girls. “The recent marketing of sexualised shirts by Cotton On Kids to be worn by babies, the provocative Little Losers line targeted at young teenagers by clothing store Jay Jays, sexually charged billboard advertising in public places, and graphic sexual music videos, dolls, and tween magazines and websites which encourage young people to look older and act older are examples of marketers crossing the line of what is acceptable and appropriate for our communities and for the protection of our children,” says Bob McCoskrie, National Director of Family First NZ.
Also in the list is 
* establish a Royal Commission of Enquiry into the real causes of child abuse,
* a number of measures to recognise and respect the role of parents, including parental notification laws and amending the antismacking law to give parents certainty under the law.
* urgent establishment of an independent CYF Complaints Authority,
* and amending the prostitution law to protect communities and families from street prostitution and residential brothels.
“The current government is attempting to stay clear of anything that might suggest social engineering,” says Mr McCoskrie. “But there are a number of social issues which this government must tackle if they wish to be respected by parents trying to raise children in an increasingly difficult culture which undermines their efforts.”READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


2. Latest Smacking Research Shows Benefits!
Family First Media Release 4 January 2010
Family First NZ is welcoming the latest research showing that light and reasonable smacking is beneficial to children in their development, and despite claims by government funded groups, kids aren’t damaged by its occasional use. “Previous research has not been able to compare children who have been smacking with those who have never been smacked, because children who’ve never been smacked were hard to find as most kids received physical discipline at least once in their life,” says Bob McCoskrie, National Director of Family First NZ. “But due to the pervading antismacking ideology, this has changed.” “Yet this study found that young children smacked by their parents may grow up to be happier and more successful than those who have never been smacked. Children smacked up to the age of six were likely as teenagers to perform better at school and were more likely to carry out volunteer work and to want to go to university than their peers who had never been physically disciplined. Only those children who continued to be smacked into adolescence showed clear behavioural problems.” READ MORE
TV3 News Coverage http://www.3news.co.nz/Smacking-may-be-beneficial---study/tabid/370/articleID/136025/Default.aspx
Family First Comment: Watch the coverage and note the classic attack by the ex-Children's Commsissioner - not on the research, but on the researcher. When academics and government appointees can't dispute the message, they just attack the messenger! (See additional reading below item #12)
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


3. Time Out Targeted as Next Taboo of Parenting
Media Release 17 January 2010
Family First NZ says that ‘time out’ is now being labeled as harmful to children based on flawed ideology and without any research to back up the claims, as was the case with the smacking debate. “Last week, an Australian parenting expert labeled time out as shameful and humiliating, joining other so-called parenting experts who claim that time out creates hurt, anger and defiance in a child ultimately harming them. They also claim that nervous habits can result, and that children should not be told they are naughty,” says Bob McCoskrie, National Director of Family First NZ. “Once again, these unsubstantiated and ideologically flawed claims and latest fads in parenting by academics simply undermine the confidence of parents to raise their children in a positive and common sense way. Where does it stop? Will it soon be unacceptable to withdraw privileges or ‘ground’ a child – perhaps it will soon be even unacceptable to frown at a child who is misbehaving!” READ MORE
Naughty corners are a bad idea for kids, according to Melbourne expert
Herald Sun January 11, 2010 READ MORE
School no place for supernanny techniques
Christchurch Press 4 April 09 READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


4. Marriage is what matters most to family stability
Mail Online (UK) 21st January 2010
Marriage is more important than all other factors in family stability, according to new research which demolishes (UK's) Labour's central argument against tax breaks for wedded couples. Harry Benson, of the Bristol Community Family Trust, said: 'Based on data of 15,000 new mothers, marriage is the single biggest predictor, above and beyond the effects of income, education, age, ethnic group, benefit receipt and birth order. Only 3% of unmarried couples stay together until their child is 16. READ MORE
READ THE FULL RESEARCH
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


5. Victims dad applauds three strikes law change
Bay of Plenty Times 20 January 2010
A Tauranga man whose daughter was murdered five years ago has welcomed the government's three-strike policy annouced yesterday. Brian Brown whose daughter Natasha Hayden was strangled to death by Michael Curren at McLaren Falls in January 2005, said the policy was a step in the right direction and "a little bit of victory" for victims of serious crime. ...While the policy has been blasted by critics including the Maori party and Corrections lobby groups, Family First NZ has welcomed it. National Director Bob McCoskrie said the policy would help ensure the safety of families from repeat violent offenders. “The best and most obvious way to protect women, children, and the elderly from repeat violent offenders is to incapacitate them. The purpose of this law will be to warn ‘career criminals’ to find a new job or else they will become ‘career inmates’. They are effectively being given two chances to stop their violent behaviour. Some would argue this is still one too many.” READ MORE
Family First Media Release Three Strikes Law will protect families READ MORE
Family First Comment: Although the law has been substantially watered down by National, it is still a step in the right direction. READ our summary on this issue including our Submission. It deals with a number of inaccurate claims made by the anti-prison lobby who fail to acknowledge that society is the victim when we fail to tackle this issue strongly. The Three Strikes law will also reinforce the "Its Not OK" message by taking victimisations seriously. A slap on the wrist for violence undermines our efforts to reduce tolerance for violence and the career choice of repeat violent offenders. Supporters of this bill do not want ‘revenge’ – they simply wish to be able to live unmolested and not in the fear of violent criminals. This is called ‘justice.’ This law is a welcome step to protect families and to encourage offenders to change their ways urgently.
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


6. Crown opposes decision that carer parents be paid
NZ Herald Jan 22, 2010
Solicitor General David Collins, QC, has said the Crown will appeal the landmark Human Rights Review Tribunal decision, delivered earlier this month, that found in favour of the families who look after their severely disabled adult children after the Ministry of Health said they were not eligible for caregivers' payments. Mr Collins said the decision to appeal was "in the public interest" because of the potential fiscal impact of the finding and its flow-on effect to other policy. The tribunal said the parents were discriminated against by the ministry because "they are not allowed to be paid for the services they provide to their child (or children) while anyone else providing the very same care to their child (or children) is able to be paid." READ MORE 
Family First Comment: This is a classic case of 'nanny state'. If the state is providing the care - they're funded, but not the parents. Similarly, if the state care for pre-schoolers - they're funded, but not stay-home mums or dads. And of course, state funded organisations determine how parents should and should not raise their kids, but not parents themselves!! Sound familiar? Unfortunately a change of government has yet to prove that this approach will change.
Got a comment on this issue? Email
feedback@familyfirst.org.nz 


7. Porn less immoral than piracy - survey
NZPA 12/01/2010
Three times as many New Zealanders think it is morally acceptable for a single person to view pornography on the internet than to download copyrighted video, according to a new poll. The survey also indicates gender differences in what is morally acceptable behaviour, with women being overall less approving of viewing pornography, using dating services, downloading copyrighted material and flirting with others on the internet. READ MORE
Child porn victims getting younger - Internal Affairs
NZ Herald Tuesday Jan 5, 2010
Children as young as a few months old are being targeted by New Zealand's child pornography offenders, as they continue to seek even younger victims. READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


8. Watching TV for hours shortens life - study
Reuters 12/01/2010
Couch potatoes, beware. Sitting in front of the television for hours daily could shorten your life, according to an Australian study. READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


9. Grieving mother blames cancer vaccine
NZ Herald Jan 9, 2010
Rhonda Renata is in no doubt about what caused the death of her daughter Jasmine. The 18-year-old died last September 22 at her family home in Upper Hutt, apparently in her sleep. It was six months since she had received the last of the three injections of the cervical cancer vaccine Gardasil. READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


10. Suicide link to a lack of sleep
Herald Sun January 04, 2010
Going to bed early is key to getting enough sleep and helping adolescents feel on top of the world, a study reports. A lack of sleep among youngsters may trigger depression and suicidal thoughts, according to the study by the Columbia University Medical Centre in New York. READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


11. Scandalous show pulled from Christmas stage
Northern Advocate 20th December 2009
A play depicting Santa raping  a reindeer has been pulled from a Whangarei stage for fear of shocking seasonal sensibilities... Family First national director Bob McCoskrie said he was "struggling to find the link between rape and Santa - it's tenuous". At Christmas it's a dark issue to be raising and you walk a fine line by bringing humour to the serious issue of rape. There's a danger you trivialise the issue." Mr McCoskrie said portraying sexual violence in a humorous way minimised its effect. The play needs to be reviewed by the chief censor so a warning can be put on for families." READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


12. ADDITIONAL READING
New Research: Why Never Smacking Might Be Worse for Kids Than Smacking Them
Newsweek Blog December 30, 2009 By Po Bronson
In NurtureShock, we described some extensive cross-ethnic and international research on spanking by Drs. Jennifer Lansford and Ken Dodge. Their data suggested that if a culture views spanking as the normal consequence for bad behavior, kids aren’t damaged by its occasional use. To explain this shocker, the scholars suggested that in cultures or communities where spanking is common, parents are less agitated when administering spankings. Spanking almost never—when combined with losing your temper—can be worse than spanking frequently.* But what about the third option: not spanking them at all? Unfortunately, there’s been little study of this, because children who’ve never been spanked aren’t easy to find. Most kids receive physical discipline at least once in their life. But times are changing, and parents today have numerous alternatives to spanking. The result is that kids are spanked less often overall, and kids who’ve never been spanked are becoming a bigger slice of the pie in long-term population studies.

One of those new population studies underway is called Portraits of American Life. It involves interviews of 2,600 people and their adolescent children every three years for the next 20 years. Dr. Marjorie Gunnoe is working with the first wave of data on the teens. It turns out that almost a quarter of these teens report they were never spanked. So this is a perfect opportunity to answer a very simple question: are kids who’ve never been spanked any better off, long term? Gunnoe’s summary is blunt: “I didn’t find that in my data.” ...What she discovered was another shocker: those who’d been spanked just when they were young—ages 2 to 6—were doing a little better as teenagers than those who’d never been spanked. On almost every measure. ..Gunnoe doesn’t know what she’ll find, but my thoughts jump immediately to the work of Dr. Sarah Schoppe-Sullivan, whom we wrote about in NurtureShock. Schoppe-Sullivan found that children of progressive dads were acting out more in school. This was likely because the fathers were inconsistent disciplinarians; they were emotionally uncertain about when and how to punish, and thus they were reinventing the wheel every time they had to reprimand their child. And there was more conflict in their marriage over how best to parent, and how to divide parenting responsibilities.
READ MORE   READ MORE 2
Pro-Spanking Studies May Have Global Effect
Newsmax.com 07 Jan 2010  By: Theodore Kettle
Two recent analyses – one psychological, the other legal – may debunk lenient modern parenting the way the Climategate e-mail scandal has short circuited global warming alarmism. READ MORE
Got a comment on this issue? Email feedback@familyfirst.org.nz


To our Christchurch supporters...
Have you seen our sign in Durham St?

If you would like a banner in your town, let us know

 



Midweek Update 16 Dec 09
1. Families Respond to Latta Review
2. Success because of your voice
3. NZ Research - Marriage Matters


1. Families Respond To Latta Review

The credibility of Family First and the credibility of the families we advocate for was attacked when the Latta report on the smacking law was released last week. The families have responded with an Open Letter, and we have highlighted the shortcomings of the report. Ultimately the Terms of Reference of this review were to go to CYF and the police, and ask whether they were applying the law correctly. Of course, they said "yes we are"!! The Prime Minister got the report he wanted, but it failed to tackle the bigger issues which we highlighted in our previous newsletter - see here

Families Reject Smacking Report and Claims of ‘Misleading’
“Why were we never consulted” - Parents
We, the parents who were accused of misrepresenting the facts of our smacking cases and therefore misleading Family First, are refuting the claims, and reject the findings of the report commissioned by the Prime Minister.

Why were we never consulted in the process? It appears that our accounts of what happened and the supporting documentation we provided, including court, police and CYF documents, to Family First has been ignored and the only opinion that matters has been that of the police and CYF. The terms of reference of the Review failed to allow our voice to be heard.

The report contains glaring errors including
• misrepresentation of basic facts,
• contains alleged actions of parents which were found to have no basis in court but which still presents the parent as being abusive,
• fails to take into account the response of the court including discharges without conviction for what were previously claimed as serious assaults
• reports a case where the police prosecution was dismissed by the court, yet the report still argues that all police action was appropriate
• fails to address a number of cases where parents were investigated by police or CYF for erroneous claims of smacking made by passers-by or the children themselves ringing 111

In one of the cases, the parent involved says: CYF fully acknowledge that their handling of this case around alleged smacking was inappropriate and breached good practice.  They have apologized, both in written form and in person, and freely acknowledge that their failure to adhere to good practice caused undue stress to the family.  Although it was certainly appropriate to investigate, the separation of the fami

Newsletter Subscription

Enter your details below to become subscribed to our email list(s).

Lists Media Release
FAMILY FIRST SUPPORTERS ALL
Forum on the Family
Stop the Abuse
MEDIA
Talkback hosts
Texts
First Name
Last Name
Email
Company
HTML
Subscribe   Unsubscribe